The CBE Scroll

Blog voices from Christians for Biblical Equality

Go and Say: The Silencing of Women’s Witness

Written by: on Sunday, February 19, 2012

Jesus said to her,

“Stop clinging to Me, for I have not yet ascended to the Father;  but go to My brethren and say to them, “I ascend to My Father and your Father, and My God and your God.” John  20:17 ( NASB) 

On the evidence of two or three witnesses a matter shall be confirmed.” (Deu. 19:15)  So said the Mosaic Law, but in Israel at the time of Jesus’ birth, Jewish tradition declared that women, along with slaves and minors, could not be called as legal witnesses. According to rabbinical consensus, the testimony of women was valueless. 

God, no respecter of human traditions, obviously had another opinion. As Joseph and Mary, in accordance with the Law, presented their forty day old Son, Jesus, at the temple, the Holy Spirit had positioned two witnesses to testify to all Israel that their prophesied Messiah had come.  One of them, Anna, was a woman. 

“And there was a prophetess, Anna the daughter of Phanuel, of the tribe of Asher.  She was advanced in years and had lived with her husband seven years after her marriage and then as a widow to the age of eighty four.  She never left the temple, serving night and day with fastings and prayers.  At that very moment she came up and began giving thanks to God, and continued to speak of Him to all those who were looking for the redemption of Jerusalem.” (Luke 2:36-38)

She spoke of Him!  And then she continued to speak of Him!  Well, isn’t that what witnesses do:  give voice to that which they have seen and heard?  The Greek word here is ‘laleo’ which translates:  ‘to utter a voice, or emit a sound” and ‘to use the tongue or faculty of speech”.   

Consider the witness of Elizabeth, filled with the Holy Spirit, as Mary approached carrying God’s Son in her womb: 

“And she cried out with a loud voice and said ‘Blessed are you among women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb!’ ” (Luke 1:42) 

No quiet, gentle greeting, this.  The original Greek likens the sound of Elizabeth’s voice here to a clamour or an outcry.  Other instances where the same Greek word for loud, ‘megas’, is used are Jesus calling forth Lazarus (John 11:43), the crowd crying out for Jesus to be crucified (Luke 23:23) and Jesus crying out His final words from the Cross (Mark 15:34, 37).  We cannot help but be left with the image of a woman compelled to give very loud and forceful voice to what she is seeing and hearing, so that none standing near could ignore her words. 

Consider also that by divine design women were present as witnesses at each crucial event in Christ’s life:   at His birth (Luke 2:7), His presentation at the temple (Luke 2:36-38), His first miracle (John 2:1-8), during His itinerant ministry (Luke 8:1-3), His death (Matt. 27:55, Luke 23:27) and His resurrection (Matthew 28:1-9).  Women disciples were also present on the Day of Pentecost when the Holy Spirit was poured out and Peter declared to the amazed onlookers “This Jesus God has raised up, of which we are all witnesses.” (Acts 1:14,15; 2:32). 

Add to these facts the clarity of the instruction Jesus gave Mary of Magdala immediately after His resurrection to “Go” and “Say” (John 20:17).  To who was she to ‘go’ and what was she to ‘say’?  To His brethren she was to declare that Christ had risen and was ascending to the Father….arguably the very core of the gospel message.  

Sadly, despite the testimony of scripture and the command of Christ Himself, church history is also the history of the silencing of women as Christ’s witnesses. In their eagerness to embrace an erroneous interpretation of Paul’s ‘women are to keep silent’ statement too many church leaders have disregarded the undeniable fact that the first person to verbally carry the gospel message was a woman.  The very direction of  Christ Himself that a woman should ‘go’ and ‘say’ has at worst been swept aside and at best been relegated to secondary importance.  Clearly, something has been amiss for a very long period of time.  

Still, throughout church history the Holy Spirit has continued to raise up women as public witnesses to the resurrection of Christ.  From the women persecuted by Saul of Tarsus (Acts 9:2) to Perpetua the third century noblewoman, tortured and torn by beasts in a Roman arena; from Blandina the slave girl of Lyons to the fourteenth century female Lollard preachers; from the sixteenth century Anne Askew, burnt at the stake, to the twenty first century female martyrs of our own time, countless women, unknown numbers with names unrecorded, continue to pay the ultimate price for the privilege of being Christ’s witnesses. 

An important question therefore begs a just and adequate answer:  Why is the blood of women martyrs acceptable to large sections of the Christian church while the vocal witness of women is not?   

Innumerable more women, serving faithfully within denominational limitations, have been denied their birthright to witness verbally, loudly and forcefully that Christ is risen and lives within them.  Misguided opposing forces have done their very best to ensure that the voices of women can no longer be heard ‘crying out with a loud voice’ as Elizabeth’s and Anna’s voices did at the dawn of Christianity.   

Writing in 1859, the holiness preacher, Phoebe Palmer, stated: “We believe that hundreds of conscientious, sensitive Christian women have actually suffered more under the slowly crucifying process to which they have been subjected by men who bear the Christian name, than many a martyr has endured in passing through the flames.” (Phoebe Palmer, Selected Writings, Thomas C. Oden.ed.New York: Paulist Press, 1988, p. 42)   

I would suggest a slight amendment to that brave statement in that the numbers would surely not be hundreds but thousands upon thousands. 

Long ago in the Garden of Eden a heartbroken God prophesied “I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your seed and her seed; He shall bruise you on the head, and you shall bruise him on the heel.” (Gen. 3:15)   

Then, at the appointed time, the voice of a woman was heard in Israel: 

“My soul exalts the Lord, and my spirit has rejoiced in God my Savior. For He has had regard for the humble state of His bondslave; for behold, from this time on all generations will count me blessed. For the Mighty One has done great things for me; and holy is His name.” (Luke 1:46-49)

The word’s of Mary of Nazareth echo down to us and cannot be silenced. To those who would teach that womankind is cursed, I say look again.  Woman is not cursed but blessed, for God has endowed her with an unique and vital role in His plan for humankind’s redemption.  In Genesis 3:15 the promised Seed was called by God “her Seed”.  Is it any wonder such words of praise and worship flowed forth from Mary’s voice that day?  In the revelation of such grace how could she possibly have kept silent?  Did she not represent all women, past and future,  when she sang from her heart “From this time on all generations will count me blessed”? 

How is it then that some sections of the church continue to demand that believing women willingly do what even the apostles Peter and John said they could not and would not do ?    

“… “for we cannot stop speaking about what we have seen and heard.” (Acts 4:20)

To the daughters of the Kingdom who still wrestle with the ‘women must be silent’ mindset, and to those who continue to struggle to be heard within the confines of patriarchal traditionalism, I would encourage you:  Find your voice and end the silence!  And when you find it ‘go and say”.  Do not stop speaking of what you have seen and heard. The brethren, the world and heaven itself strain to hear the sound of your testimony that Christ is risen and indeed we are His witnesses. 

7 Comments »

Comment by Sarah Goebel

February 21, 2012 @ 12:38 am

When I first came to know Christ, I was so excited, I couldn’t keep silent! Not knowing any better, I witnessed all I knew of Him to every one I met. I just wanted to shout from the roof tops of God’s grace and mercy! I once witnessed to a homeless man whom God allowed to find his way to our barn. My husband would leave for work, I would send the children off to school and then invite him in for breakfast. For two weeks straight, I fried him eggs and bacon and gave him juice and coffee. I sat at the table with my bible open, and read Scripture to Him until, one day, He asked how he could be saved and I led him in prayer. Praise God! Unfortunately, little by little over the years, I have experienced correction, and persecution until I became more and more reluctant to speak. I looked for a safe way to share Jesus and began sharing the Word of God to “only women”. Eventually, I started broadcasting over the internet using my limited resources. The church was not real happy about that but I still got away with it. I tried to discipline my tongue from doing anything that might offend the men. Nonetheless, I still seemed to offend them all along the way, and frankly, it hurt!It made me feel at times as if something was wrong with me. I enjoyed your blog post because I have always felt that Jesus was really trying to make a statement when He allowed Mary to be the first to “go and tell” about His resurrection! I just knew it! Yet, I couldn’t seem to put the pieces together to make sense of the verses that seemed to prohibit women from sharing in ministry until I found CBE a few months ago. Last August, we left a church after I was corrected for reading a Scripture aloud in the presence of men while standing beside my husband at the front of the church. We had moved from NC to CA and had not been at this church all that long and didn’t realize their views were even stricter than what I had been exposed to for the twenty years prior to this incident. Anyway, after we left, I think it was November that in one of my Google searches, CBE miraculously came up. I thought, “uhmmmm”, “what is this” and I eagerly checked it out. I feel as though I have been set free from years of oppression and chained feet! After reading several articles, I shared with my husband. He is now a believer too!!! Now I know that it was the Spirit of the Lord showing me all along, through His purposeful design to have Mary see Him risen before the men; and His command to her to “go” and “tell” the others, what we were living and teaching was not the “full” gospel! I knew it deep in my heart, but I didn’t dig deep enough to be able to explain what I knew. I regret that as I am older now and not quite as energetic or something. Perhaps it is just the wounding. I am praying for healing from the wounds of the past, experienced because I was a woman who wanted to “tell” about Christ; and, I am waiting on the Lord for direction. I feel that I am at a standstill with ministry work as I am so busy reading all I can on the topic of mutual equality. It is all I can think of right now. Perhaps God will allow me to serve Him again in the future without fear of what the men are going to say! I am grateful to have found CBE. Thank you!

Comment by JDM

February 21, 2012 @ 9:04 am

Thanks, Sarah, for your inspiring response!

Comment by Trevor

February 21, 2012 @ 5:07 pm

Thank God you didn’t give up entirely Sarah after such terrible discouragement from the men in the churches you attended at that time in your life. Just looking at your web page you’ve certainly been busy sharing your gifts over the internet. I’m sure that God will continue to open doors for you now that you’ve found encouragement and supportive, Biblical scholarship through the ministry of CBE.

Comment by Cheryl

February 21, 2012 @ 5:56 pm

Sarah, I love your story about the homeless man. I couldn’t help reflecting that since it’s by the action of the Holy Spirit a person is born again into God’s Kingdom, why would the Holy Spirit come alongside you in teaching this man if what you were doing was rebellious and against God’s Word?

You also shared “Perhaps it is just the wounding. I am praying for healing from the wounds of the past, experienced because I was a woman who wanted to “tell” about Christ;”

I believe there are multitudes of women inside and outside organised Christianity who would echo your sentiments. Recently I was warmly affirmed verbally by a brother, and it brought sudden and unexpected tears of surprised gratitude to my eyes. I realised that even for many of us who do walk in the fullness of our freedom, there are buried traces of rejection left over from what we have experienced over many years in church life. We all need healing and it comes through walking in freedom together, male and female.

Comment by Sarah Goebel

February 21, 2012 @ 11:38 pm

Cheryl,
You said, “why would the Holy Spirit come alongside you in teaching this man if what you were doing was rebellious and against God’s Word?” Those were exactly my thoughts too! I have never understood the erroneous teaching about women, but I tried to live by it the best I could because everyone in my sphere of influence kept telling me that it was God’s will. My husband always had some questions as well, although he was a Pastor, ordained through a group that at one time insisted women wear doylies on their heads when in the “sanctuary”. They had progressed from that before we were involved. Praise God! The great thing is my husband is right by my side, seeing eye-to-eye on this issue, and we are now sharing this new freedom with our adult son, daughter and her son and a couple we got close to at the church we attended for about a year after we moved to CA. We are doing a study from “Partners in Marriage and Ministry” and everyone is seeing it clearly. My girlfriend, Barbara, continues to say, “wow”.

We are going to contact CBE tomorrow to inquire about starting a CBE chapter here. Thanks for your prayers regarding healing. I praise God that you have been able to overcome even though there may still be ‘traces of rejection’ in your heart. Perhaps the traces of rejection are left to be just enough to motivate and empower you and the message of the full gospel.

Comment by Sarah Goebel

February 21, 2012 @ 11:51 pm

Trevor,
Thank you for your comment and encouragement. Yes, it has not been easy, yet, I could not be still. Thus, the books and internet and some speaking engagements to women’s groups. My ministry caused my husband and I to be the black sheep of the churches, and that was discouraging at times. In the past couple of years, I have slowed down and have felt heavy in my spirit. So I have not been very active except for blogging with the Christians Read group. I guess I had just grown weary. I am feeling that fire again in my spirit so we will see what happens. I think God is educating my husband and me right now and is going to do a “new thing” with us! We no longer have ministry ties with the old organization or church we were associated with and we are free to follow Christ! Thank you, again, for your response!

Comment by Sarah Goebel

February 21, 2012 @ 11:52 pm

God is so amazing!

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Bad Behavior has blocked 346 access attempts in the last 7 days.